發文作者:kahoo | 八月 9, 2006

你贊不贊成香港取消中學會考制度?


Responses

  1. Hi Simon,

    Another good subject today!

    Imagine if our Canadian system is used by Hong Kong, both the students and parents will try corrupting the teachers or principals for higher marks every single day!

    Better stay with the evil public exam.

  2. HKCEE’s totally useless. Why is it there in the first place? Decades ago there may not be enough resources to let everyone study F6, F7, etc. Nowadays there are enough teachers (schools are closing because there are not enough students). HK can easily provide free education for everyone until University.

  3. Hi Simon,

    Today’s news only represented the 15 minutes of fame for those top students.

    For all the 10A graduates of past years, I would be interested to know where are they now?

  4. 由於節目時間不長﹐想給其他聽眾發表意見﹐我就沒有HOLD了~ 就讓我在這說說我還沒說完的吧~~

    我覺得不需要取消﹐因為如果取消後香港走像這裡的制度是行不通的(但主要原因不是因為像GARY所說的那樣)﹐可是制度絕對需要改善。香港的會考製度太恐怖,一Q可以清袋(或一鳴驚人﹖)﹐如果剛巧狀態不好﹐那就真的ORZ了。要說香港跟的是英國制度﹐但節目中葉SIR也提過﹐英國是校內和公開試分數結合計算的﹐並不是香港那樣子–只用會考成績的制度﹐實在非常不完善。

    取消後走像這裡的制度為什麼行不通﹖
    香港由小學升中學就已經用成績分類過﹐所以中學彼此之間的程度都有頗大的懸殊﹐若像這裡般只計校內成績明顯不妥。至於會有家長做些甚麼來討好老師這說法﹐我不排除這種事會發生﹐但卻不覺得它會成為一個普遍的問題。一個學生讀書成勣如何﹐是由不同學科不同老師一起評定﹐而且其他同學也會知道那學生的程度﹐老師做『手腳』會十分明顯。

    Anyways,書還是要讀、試仍是要考的。只是希望大家給香港的學生們多幾條生路﹐不要增加他們的壓力了﹔尤其是那些來至社會上的大肆渲染﹐無形的壓力其實殺傷力是最大的。

  5. Friends, just to remind you that I described the exam as an evil exam! I do hate it very much!

    Without support (esp. emotional support) from family, teachers and friends, the road to success is very tough!

    I have an interesting observation: the government officials in Hong Kong, I guess, should have very good public exam results. However, since the British left Hong Kong, all new gov’t policies failed! Why? I am 100% it has to do with the whole education system, not just the evil of the public exams.

  6. The public exam should stay but it will require major overhaul. It should be held not once but at least multiple times a year, the final mark of each subject is then averaged. Personally, I would like the exam be given monthly, but you can take the best of any three scores. By the way, the exam should be also held in student’s own school, using a computer terminal to answer exam questions. For those who finish earlier, he or she can move on to work or continue study. This is my one cent advice.


發表迴響

在下方填入你的資料或按右方圖示以社群網站登入:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / 變更 )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / 變更 )

Facebook照片

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / 變更 )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / 變更 )

連結到 %s

分類

%d 位部落客按了讚: